'Earning woman able to maintain herself': Allahabad HC sets aside maintenance order
LUCKNOW: In a significant decision, the Allahabad High Court set aside an order passed by the lower court of Gautam Buddh Nagar mandating a man to pay maintenance to his estranged wife, observing that she earned her living and did not reveal the true salary in her affidavit. The bench comprising Justice Madan Pal Singh also allowed a criminal revision petition filed by the man Ankit Saha. A perusal of the impugned judgment indicates that in the affidavit filed before the trial court, the opposite party herself admitted that she is a post-graduate and a web designer by qualification. She is working as a senior sales coordinator in a company and getting a salary of Rs 34,000 per month, the court said in the order dated December 3. But in her cross-examination, she has admitted that she was earning Rs 36,000 per month. Such an amount for a wife who has no other liability cannot be said to be meagre; whereas the man has the responsibility of maintaining his aged parents and other social obligations, it observed. The High Court observed that the woman was not entitled to get any maintenance from her husband as she is an earning lady and able to maintain herself. The man's counsel argued in court that the estranged wife did not reveal the whole truth in the affidavit. She claimed herself to be an illiterate and unemployed woman. When the document filed by the man was shown to her before the trial court, she admitted her income during cross-examination. Thus, it is clear that she did not come before the trial court with clean hands, said the mans counsel while making his submissions. The court, in its order, said, Cases of those litigants who have no regard for the truth and those who indulge in suppressing material facts need to be thrown out of the court. It impugned the lower court's February 17 judgment and order, passed by the principal judge of a family court in Gautam Buddh Nagar and allowed the criminal revision petition filed by the man.
13 C
